Advertisement
Case Report| Volume 29, ISSUE 2, P239-242, June 2018

Download started.

Ok

Close Encounter With a Prickly Soccer Ball: An Injury From an Indian Crested Porcupine

Published:March 09, 2018DOI:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wem.2018.01.003
      The Indian crested porcupine, Hystrix indica, is a large rodent with the unique feature of long quills. These quills are an integral part of its defense mechanism against predators. Injuries resulting from human contact with quills may cause pain, bleeding, and swelling. Quill-related injuries are common among animals such as dogs, cats, and some wild animals. The mechanism of injury, consequences, and management of injuries to humans from H indica quills are rarely described. In this report, we describe the injuries and management of a man who sustained injury from H indica quills.

      Keywords

      Introduction

      The Indian crested porcupine, Hystrix indica (Figure 1, A), is a large rodent that has been recorded from southwest and central Asia including India, Nepal, Pakistan, China, and Sri Lanka. It is also found in Turkey and the eastern Mediterranean region.

      The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2016. Hystrix indica. Amori G, Hutterer R, Kryštufek B, Yigit N, Mitsain G, Palomo LJ, assessors. Available at: http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/10751/0. Accessed May 2017.

      • Phillips W.W.
      It is a nocturnal, mostly vegetarian mammal.
      • Yapa A.C.
      • Ratnavira G.
      The Mammals of Sri Lanka..
      Porcupines are covered in multiple layers of quills, which are essentially modified hair and play an important role in defense against predators.
      • Phillips W.W.
      Figure
      Figure 1A, Indian crested porcupine Hystrix indica. B, Injured left foot of the patient. C, Close-up of the injury in B. D, Scanning electron microscopy images of the structure of a Hystrix indica quill with scales on the cortex surface of the black tip. E, Hystrix indica quill.
      Injuries caused by quills range from minor peripheral penetrating injuries (eg, limbs) to internal organ penetration subsequently leading to death from peritonitis.
      • McDade H.C.
      • Crandell W.B.
      Perforation of the gastrointestinal tract by an unusual foreign body; a porcupine quill; report of two cases.
      • Jorge L.M.
      • Bernardes Filho F.
      • Lamy F.
      • Balassiano L.K.
      • Towersey L.
      • Hay R.
      • et al.
      Clinical manifestation, histopathology, and imaging of traumatic injuries caused by Brazilian porcupine (Sphiggurus villosus) quills.
      Injuries related to porcupine quills are common among several species of animals,
      • Johnson M.D.
      • Magnusson K.D.
      • Shmon C.L.
      • Waldner C.
      Porcupine quill injuries in dogs: a retrospective of 296 cases (1998–2002).
      and reported quill-related injuries to humans are most typically from relatively small quill-bearing porcupines (Table 1). However, the mechanism of injury, sequelae, and management of H indica quill-related injuries in humans are rarely described.
      Table 1Summary of reports on porcupine quill-related injuries to humans
      Location and year of incidentSpeciesPatient age, sex, and occupationIncident and injury
      Adıyaman, Turkey; 2017
      • Aydin I.
      • Apaydin H.O.
      • Dokuzoglu M.A.
      • Guler O.
      • Tunc I.
      Two cases of injuries with porcupine quill.
      Year of publication.
      Possibly Indian crested porcupine; Hystrix indica17 y; male; NRQuill penetration on the dorsum of the foot while walking on land
      5 y; female; NRFell on porcupine quill while playing with it and the quill penetrated the periumblical area
      Rio de Janeiro, Brazil; 2016
      • Jorge L.M.
      • Bernardes Filho F.
      • Lamy F.
      • Balassiano L.K.
      • Towersey L.
      • Hay R.
      • et al.
      Clinical manifestation, histopathology, and imaging of traumatic injuries caused by Brazilian porcupine (Sphiggurus villosus) quills.
      Year of publication.
      Possibly orange-spined hairy dwarf porcupine; Sphiggurus villosus52 y; female; NRPorcupine dropped from a lamppost onto to the patients’ head while walking
      Espírito Santo, Brazil; 2016
      • Jorge L.M.
      • Bernardes Filho F.
      • Lamy F.
      • Balassiano L.K.
      • Towersey L.
      • Hay R.
      • et al.
      Clinical manifestation, histopathology, and imaging of traumatic injuries caused by Brazilian porcupine (Sphiggurus villosus) quills.
      Year of publication.
      Possibly orange-spined hairy dwarf porcupine; S villosus20 y; male; NRKicked porcupine with right foot while riding a motorcycle
      Texas, USA; 2016
      • Lamkin C.
      • Hamner L.R.
      An unusual cause of pericardial effusion.
      Year of publication.
      NR49 y; female; NRUnknowingly ingested a porcupine quill, which caused a perforation in the esophagus and aorta, and bleed caused pericardial effusion
      Niterói, Brazil; 2016
      • Bernardes Filho F.
      • Andrade J.C.
      • Queiroz D.L.
      • Lupi O.
      Brazilian porcupine quill injuries.
      Year of publication.
      Brazilian porcupine; S. villosus50 y; male; NRHit porcupine with right hand to frighten it away
      São Paulo, Brazil; 2010
      • Haddad V.J.
      • Vieira R.B.
      • Cortes C.R.
      Hand injuries in a human caused by a South American porcupine (ourio-cacheiro).
      Year of publication.
      South American porcupine34 y; male; NR (tourist)Saw a porcupine in the woods near holiday house and tried to capture it with right hand
      Vermont, USA; 1954
      • McDade H.C.
      • Crandell W.B.
      Perforation of the gastrointestinal tract by an unusual foreign body; a porcupine quill; report of two cases.
      Year of incident.
      NR51 y; male; woodsmanUnknowingly swallowed quill with food and perforated small intestine
      Montana, USA; 1954
      • Harlowe H.D.
      Unusual foreign body (porcupine quill) in the esophagus; case report.
      Year of publication.
      NR87 y; female; NRUnknowingly swallowed quill with food and quill embedded in esophagus
      Maine, USA; 1951
      • Hill F.T.
      Porcupine quills as laryngeal foreign bodies.
      Year of publication.
      NR58 y; female; farmer’s wifeUnknowingly swallowed quill with food and quill became stuck in laryngeal region
      NR23 y; male; telephone linesmanUnknowingly swallowed quill while drinking water from a jug and quill became stuck in laryngeal region
      Montana, USA; 1935
      • Garberson J.H.
      Perforation of intestine from unusual foreign body (porcupine quill).
      Year of incident.
      NR23 y; male; NRUnknowingly swallowed quill while drinking water or eating food and quill perforated small intestine
      New Hampshire, USA; 1934
      • McDade H.C.
      • Crandell W.B.
      Perforation of the gastrointestinal tract by an unusual foreign body; a porcupine quill; report of two cases.
      Year of incident.
      NR30 y; maleAte porcupine meat sandwich and quill perforated stomach and intestine, resulting in diffuse peritonitis. Patient died 8 days after surgery.
      NR, not reported.
      a Year of publication.
      b Year of incident.
      We describe the case of a man who sustained injuries from contact with H indica quills and recovered with appropriate management without subsequent complications.

      Case Presentation

      A 50-year-old farmer was on his way home, riding a motorbike at high speed. His left foot collided with a porcupine that was crossing the road, and 6 quills were embedded in the dorsum of his left foot. He experienced severe pain and mild bleeding from the wounds. He sought medical care from a primary care hospital (Galnewa District Hospital) within half an hour of the incident. At Galnewa District Hospital, the quills were removed with pliers, and prophylactic intravenous cefuroxime 750 mg and metronidazole 500 mg were administered every 8 h. Diclofenac sodium (100 mg every 12 h orally) was provided for analgesia.
      The patient was transferred to a tertiary care hospital (Teaching Hospital Anuradhapura) the next day due to persistent swelling of the foot. The examination at the Teaching Hospital Anuradhapura revealed that the left foot was swollen, and 6 quill marks were found on the dorsum of the left foot (Figure 1, B and C). No infection, bleeding, or groin lymphadenopathy was observed. Apart from mild pain at the site, the patient was conscious, rational, and all other vital parameters were stable. The previously prescribed medications were continued, and he was advised to keep the foot elevated. Four days later, his symptoms and signs abated and he was discharged. He was reexamined after 3 weeks and no complications from the injury were noted.

      Discussion

      Porcupines belong to 2 main families: Old World (African or Indian crested porcupine; Hystricidae) and New World (Erethizontidae).
      • Yang W.
      • Chao C.
      • McKittrick J.
      Axial compression of a hollow cylinder filled with foam: a study of porcupine quills.
      The Indian crested porcupine can adapt to a wide range of habitats and food types.

      The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2016. Hystrix indica. Amori G, Hutterer R, Kryštufek B, Yigit N, Mitsain G, Palomo LJ, assessors. Available at: http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/10751/0. Accessed May 2017.

      Average adults weigh 11 to 15 kg with a length of approximately 66 to 77 cm (with the tail measuring 13-18 cm).
      • Phillips W.W.
      Quills are typically 15 to 30 cm in length but can grow up to 51 cm (20 inches; Figure 1, E).
      • Phillips W.W.
      The longer quills are located on the neck and shoulder region, and the smaller, more rigid ones are packed on the back and rump.
      • Yapa A.C.
      • Ratnavira G.
      The Mammals of Sri Lanka..
      Quills are made of keratin and connected to a muscle at the base, which allows the porcupine to raise the quills when threatened and make the porcupine appear bigger.
      • Phillips W.W.
      • Yapa A.C.
      • Ratnavira G.
      The Mammals of Sri Lanka..
      • Mori E.
      • Maggini I.
      • Menchetti M.
      When quills kill: The defense strategy of the crested porcupine Hystrix cristata L., 1758.
      Furthermore, the porcupine can stamp its feet, growl or grunt, and rattle the hollow quills at the back of its tail.
      • Hennessy D.J.
      Green Aisles: A Story of the Jungles of Ceylon..
      These actions will deter most predators. Sometimes porcupines swing their quill-covered tails toward the potential threat and move backward.
      • Phillips W.W.
      These mechanisms enable the porcupine to release the quills into the offending animal’s body.
      • Hennessy D.J.
      Green Aisles: A Story of the Jungles of Ceylon..
      Contrary to popular belief, porcupines cannot shoot their quills when agitated.
      • Woods C.A.
      Erethizon dorsatum.
      The barbs on the quills of the North American porcupine permit easy penetration into the victim’s tissue.
      • Cho W.K.
      • Ankrum J.A.
      • Guo D.
      • Chester S.A.
      • Yang S.Y.
      • Kashyap A.
      • et al.
      Microstructured barbs on the North American porcupine quill enable easy tissue penetration and difficult removal.
      The strong adhesion in the tissue is due to the backward-facing spread of the scales, which makes removal difficult.
      • Cho W.K.
      • Ankrum J.A.
      • Guo D.
      • Chester S.A.
      • Yang S.Y.
      • Kashyap A.
      • et al.
      Microstructured barbs on the North American porcupine quill enable easy tissue penetration and difficult removal.
      The scales on the tip of the quills of the Hysterix spp are irregular,
      • Yang W.
      • Chao C.
      • McKittrick J.
      Axial compression of a hollow cylinder filled with foam: a study of porcupine quills.
      which may make removal difficult compared with foreign objects that have smooth surfaces (Figure 1, D).
      The incidence of H indica quill-induced injuries in humans is rare in the literature.
      • Aydin I.
      • Apaydin H.O.
      • Dokuzoglu M.A.
      • Guler O.
      • Tunc I.
      Two cases of injuries with porcupine quill.
      The reported cases of porcupine quill injuries are summarized in Table 1. The majority of cases reported in the literature are from North and South America, and there is one from Turkey. Some reports describe accidental swallowing of quills, leading to penetrating injuries in the gastrointestinal tract. The smaller size of the quill could be the reason for unknowingly swallowing the quills. Other described external injuries have been less severe, and it is notable that these were primarily caused by New World porcupine species (Table 1). External injuries caused by contact with H indica quills can be more serious because of its proportionately larger size.
      Porcupine quill injuries often lead to pain, bleeding, swelling, and probably an increased risk of secondary infection due to environmental exposure of the wound to bacteria. Therefore, the affected skin surface should be thoroughly cleansed, and the patient should be administered antibiotics to cover both gram-positive cocci and anaerobes.
      • Aydin I.
      • Apaydin H.O.
      • Dokuzoglu M.A.
      • Guler O.
      • Tunc I.
      Two cases of injuries with porcupine quill.
      • Haddad V.J.
      • Vieira R.B.
      • Cortes C.R.
      Hand injuries in a human caused by a South American porcupine (ourio-cacheiro).
      Tetanus toxoid is also recommended. Quills should be firmly gripped with pliers and removed by applying a strong force directly opposite to the direction of penetration without twisting or breaking the quills. Radiography (x-ray or computed tomography) may assist in assessing the depth of the penetration and rule out any internal injuries before careful removal of the quills.
      Pain management should be based on the severity of pain (visual analogue scale can be used to assess the level of pain). If there is evidence of bleeding, it can be stopped by applying firm pressure on the site or elevating the affected area.
      • Jorge L.M.
      • Bernardes Filho F.
      • Lamy F.
      • Balassiano L.K.
      • Towersey L.
      • Hay R.
      • et al.
      Clinical manifestation, histopathology, and imaging of traumatic injuries caused by Brazilian porcupine (Sphiggurus villosus) quills.
      H indica is considered an agricultural pest in some regions because it may be destructive to gardens and agricultural crops.
      • Phillips W.W.
      Porcupines are widely hunted for meat and for medicinal use.
      • Rajabloo M.
      • Razavi S.M.
      • Shayegh H.
      • Alavi A.M.
      Nymphal linguatulosis in Indian crested porcupines (Histrix indica) in Southwest of Iran.
      • Landreth N.
      • Saito O.
      An ecosystem services approach to sustainable livelihoods in the homegardens of Kandy, Sri Lanka.
      The individuals who are most prone to sustaining porcupine injuries are hunters, hikers, backpackers, and those who visit forests to gather medicinal herbs, honey, firewood, or livestock. All risk groups should be aware of unexpected contact with porcupines because this may cause quill-induced injuries.
      People who travel at night should be aware of the nocturnal habits of porcupines and be alert to their potential presence in immediate surroundings. Travelers should carry a light source (head lamp) to visualize the animal at a distance and avoid it. Although porcupines have a keen sense of smell, they have poor eyesight and should be given a wide berth.
      • Woods C.A.
      Erethizon dorsatum.
      Indian crested porcupines are terrestrial animals; hence, most injuries may occur to the lower limbs. Therefore, it is advisable to wear footwear that is impervious to penetrating injuries when traversing the jungle. If faced with an aggressive porcupine, it is advisable to walk slowly away from the porcupine, leaving plenty of room and time for the porcupine to leave the area.
      Acknowledgments: The authors thank Mr Ishan Senaverathne for the image of an Indian crested porcupine in captivity at the National Zoological Gardens of Sri Lanka. The authors also acknowledge the help extended by Drs Sunil De Alwis (Deputy Director General of Health Services; Training Research) and N. Ekanayake (Director Medical Research Institute) as well as Mr K. Wickramarathne (Technical Officer-in-Charge of Electron Microscope, Medical Research Institute) for facilitating the electron microscopy photographs of Indian crested porcupine quills. The authors especially thank the editorial team of the Wilderness & Environmental Medicine Journal for their continuous support to improve this manuscript as well as the 2 anonymous reviewers for their constructive comments, which helped to improve the manuscript.
      Authors Contributions: Study concept (SPBT); literature review and drafting and editing of the manuscript (SPBT, BTBW); data collection (BDBT).
      Financial/Material Support: None.
      Disclosures: None.

      References

      1. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2016. Hystrix indica. Amori G, Hutterer R, Kryštufek B, Yigit N, Mitsain G, Palomo LJ, assessors. Available at: http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/10751/0. Accessed May 2017.

        • Phillips W.W.
        Mannual of the Mammals of Sri Lanka. 2nd ed. Wildlife and Nature Protection Society of Sri Lanka, Colombo1980
        • Yapa A.C.
        • Ratnavira G.
        The Mammals of Sri Lanka..
        Field Ornithology Group of Sri Lanka, Department of Zoology, University of Colombo, Colombo2013
        • McDade H.C.
        • Crandell W.B.
        Perforation of the gastrointestinal tract by an unusual foreign body; a porcupine quill; report of two cases.
        N Engl J Med. 1958; 258: 746-747
        • Jorge L.M.
        • Bernardes Filho F.
        • Lamy F.
        • Balassiano L.K.
        • Towersey L.
        • Hay R.
        • et al.
        Clinical manifestation, histopathology, and imaging of traumatic injuries caused by Brazilian porcupine (Sphiggurus villosus) quills.
        Case Rep Dermatol Med. 2016; 2016: 7851986
        • Johnson M.D.
        • Magnusson K.D.
        • Shmon C.L.
        • Waldner C.
        Porcupine quill injuries in dogs: a retrospective of 296 cases (1998–2002).
        Can Vet J. 2006; 47: 677-682
        • Yang W.
        • Chao C.
        • McKittrick J.
        Axial compression of a hollow cylinder filled with foam: a study of porcupine quills.
        Acta Biomater. 2013; 9: 5297-5304
        • Mori E.
        • Maggini I.
        • Menchetti M.
        When quills kill: The defense strategy of the crested porcupine Hystrix cristata L., 1758.
        Mammalia. 2014; 78: 229-234
        • Hennessy D.J.
        Green Aisles: A Story of the Jungles of Ceylon..
        Colombo Book Centre, Colombo1949
        • Woods C.A.
        Erethizon dorsatum.
        Mammal Species. 1973; 29: 1-6
        • Cho W.K.
        • Ankrum J.A.
        • Guo D.
        • Chester S.A.
        • Yang S.Y.
        • Kashyap A.
        • et al.
        Microstructured barbs on the North American porcupine quill enable easy tissue penetration and difficult removal.
        Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2012; 109: 21289-21294
        • Aydin I.
        • Apaydin H.O.
        • Dokuzoglu M.A.
        • Guler O.
        • Tunc I.
        Two cases of injuries with porcupine quill.
        J Emerg Med Case Rep. 2017; 8: 49-51
        • Haddad V.J.
        • Vieira R.B.
        • Cortes C.R.
        Hand injuries in a human caused by a South American porcupine (ourio-cacheiro).
        J Venom Anim Toxins Incl Trop Dis. 2010; 16: 382-386
        • Rajabloo M.
        • Razavi S.M.
        • Shayegh H.
        • Alavi A.M.
        Nymphal linguatulosis in Indian crested porcupines (Histrix indica) in Southwest of Iran.
        J Arthropod Borne Dis. 2014; 9: 131-136
        • Landreth N.
        • Saito O.
        An ecosystem services approach to sustainable livelihoods in the homegardens of Kandy, Sri Lanka.
        Austr Geograph. 2014; 45: 355-373
        • Lamkin C.
        • Hamner L.R.
        An unusual cause of pericardial effusion.
        JAAPA. 2016; 29: 32-34
        • Bernardes Filho F.
        • Andrade J.C.
        • Queiroz D.L.
        • Lupi O.
        Brazilian porcupine quill injuries.
        J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2016; 30: 530-532
        • Harlowe H.D.
        Unusual foreign body (porcupine quill) in the esophagus; case report.
        Laryngoscope. 1954; 64: 691-692
        • Hill F.T.
        Porcupine quills as laryngeal foreign bodies.
        Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1951; 60: 751-753
        • Garberson J.H.
        Perforation of intestine from unusual foreign body (porcupine quill).
        J Lancet. 1937; 57: 277-278